Why James Packer Paid $1.8m to Benjamin Netanyahu’s Defense Lawyers

Why James Packer Paid $1.8m to Benjamin Netanyahu’s Defense Lawyers

Paying $1.8 million to an Israeli law firm isn't a casual Tuesday expense, even if you're a billionaire. Yet that's exactly what Australian casino mogul James Packer did, funneling massive legal fees into Hadad Roth Shenhar & Co.—the very same Tel Aviv firm representing Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in his ongoing corruption trial.

When this story broke, the internet immediately jumped to conspiracy theories. Did Packer buy influence? Was he secretly bankrolling Netanyahu's personal defense?

The truth is way more complicated, legally messy, and frankly, a textbook lesson in how billionaire damage control actually works behind closed doors. If you want to understand why James Packer paid $1.8m to Benjamin Netanyahu's defense lawyers, you have to look at the timeline of Israel's infamous "Case 1000" and how high-stakes corporate litigation crosses borders.

The Real Reason Behind the $1.8 Million Payment

Let's clear the air right away. Packer didn't write a blank check to cover Benjamin Netanyahu's personal legal bills. At least, not according to the official financial disclosures and legal filings that brought this payment to light.

Instead, that $1.8 million (roughly 6 million Israeli shekels at the time) went toward Packer's own legal representation in Israel. Specifically, Amit Hadad—the powerhouse defense attorney leading Netanyahu's legal team—also represented Packer during the police investigations surrounding Case 1000.

Wait a second. Can one lawyer represent both the prime minister accused of taking illegal gifts and the billionaire accused of giving them?

In Israel, that's where things get tricky. Under normal circumstances, representing two central figures in the same criminal investigation screams conflict of interest. Hadad had to navigate strict ethical boundaries, eventually stepping back from certain aspects of Packer's representation once the investigation crystallized into formal charges against Netanyahu and Packer was officially designated as a key prosecution witness.

Still, the money already moved. Between 2017 and 2020, Packer's corporate entities transferred roughly $1.8 million to Hadad Roth Shenhar & Co. For context, that's an astronomical sum for a witness who was never even charged with a crime in Israel.

What Is Case 1000 and Why Was Packer Involved

You can't separate these legal fees from the gifts at the center of Case 1000. If you haven't followed Israeli politics closely over the last decade, Case 1000 is the "illegal gifts" affair—one of three corruption cases brought against Benjamin Netanyahu.

Prosecutors alleged that between 2007 and 2016, Netanyahu and his wife, Sara, received hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of luxury items from two wealthy businessmen: Hollywood producer Arnon Milchan and Australian billionaire James Packer.

We aren't talking about fruit baskets. The indictment listed boxes of expensive Cohiba cigars, crates of pink champagne, and luxury jewelry. According to Israeli police and state prosecutors, Packer alone supplied roughly 229,000 shekels (around $65,000 USD at the time) worth of cigars and champagne to the Netanyahus between 2014 and 2016.

Why would an Australian casino magnate drop tens of thousands of dollars on cigars for an Israeli politician?

Prosecutors argued it wasn't just friendship. Packer was actively seeking Israeli residency status at the time, which carried massive tax benefits for wealthy foreign residents. He also had overlapping business interests with Milchan, including a proposed cybersecurity venture and a joint production company. While Packer was never charged with bribery—because prosecutors concluded he didn't receive concrete political favors in return—his testimony became a cornerstone of the breach of trust charges against Netanyahu.

Think about the math here. Packer allegedly spent around $65,000 on cigars and champagne, and then ended up spending $1.8 million on lawyers to deal with the fallout. That's nearly thirty times the value of the gifts themselves.

Why Witnesses Spend Millions on Defense Attorneys

Most people hear "witness" and assume you just show up, tell the truth, and go home. That's how it works on TV. In real-life international white-collar investigations, being a "mere witness" is a legal tightrope walk over a pit of sharks.

When Israeli police started digging into Case 1000, Packer wasn't just casually answering questions over coffee. He was facing intense scrutiny from the Lahav 433 unit—essentially Israel's version of the FBI. Everything he said to Israeli investigators could instantly bleed into his business empire back home in Australia.

At that exact moment, Packer's flagship company, Crown Resorts, was fighting for its corporate life. Australian regulators in New South Wales, Victoria, and Western Australia were launching brutal public inquiries into Crown's casino licenses, money laundering failures, and junket operators.

If Packer admitted to anything resembling bribery or improper influence in Israel, Australian gaming regulators would have used it as ammunition to strip Crown of its licenses immediately. Every single word he uttered to Israeli police had to be vetted by top-tier lawyers who understood both Israeli criminal procedure and international corporate fallout.

You don't hire a discount lawyer when a billion-dollar casino license hangs in the balance. You hire the most connected, aggressive legal mind in Tel Aviv. And in 2017, that person was Amit Hadad.

How the $1.8 Million Figure Became Public

Billionaires hate having their legal invoices published in the press. So how did we find out the exact $1.8 million figure?

It leaked out through a combination of Israeli transparency petitions, media investigations by outlets like Haaretz and The Marker, and regulatory disclosures tied to Netanyahu's own requests to fund his defense.

Netanyahu repeatedly asked Israel's State Comptroller and the Permits Committee for permission to accept millions of dollars from wealthy foreign donors—including his cousin Nathan Milikowsky and American businessman Spencer Partrich—to pay his own skyrocketing legal bills with Hadad's firm. Because Netanyahu's legal finances were under a microscope, the financial ecosystem surrounding Hadad Roth Shenhar & Co. became fair game for investigative journalists.

When reporters cross-referenced Packer's corporate disclosures and Israeli legal filings, the $1.8 million payment jumped off the page. Critics immediately questioned whether Packer's massive retainer indirectly subsidized the firm's bandwidth to defend Netanyahu, even if the invoices were technically separate.

There is zero hard evidence that Packer's money paid for Netanyahu's legal hours. Law firms bill clients separately, and Hadad's firm maintained strict accounting walls. Still, in politics, optics matter almost as much as receipts. Having a key prosecution witness pay nearly two million dollars to the defendant's lead lawyer looks terrible, no matter how clean the bookkeeping is.

The Fallout for Crown Resorts and Packer's Testimony

Packer eventually gave testimony via video link from Australia in 2022, after years of delays citing his well-documented mental health struggles. His testimony was underwhelming for anyone expecting dramatic courtroom fireworks.

He confirmed he gave cigars and champagne to the Netanyahus. He insisted he viewed Netanyahu as a friend and admired him as a leader. He denied expecting any political favors in return. Honestly, it was the exact kind of careful, middle-of-the-road testimony you get when a witness spends $1.8 million preparing for a few hours on camera.

Meanwhile, the broader storm around Packer's business practices didn't go away. The Bergin Inquiry in New South Wales found Crown Resorts unfit to hold a Sydney casino license, citing money laundering vulnerabilities and governance failures. Packer eventually stepped back from the board and sold his massive stake in Crown to Blackstone in 2022 for roughly $3.3 billion AUD.

Looking back, that $1.8 million legal bill in Israel was just one line item in a decade-long global cleanup operation.

What This Reveals About Cross-Border Legal Defense

If you ever find yourself analyzing high-profile corporate scandals or political corruption trials, don't just follow the alleged bribes. Follow the legal retainers.

Here's what actually happens when billionaires get tangled up in foreign political investigations:

  • Legal fees dwarf the alleged misconduct. When reputation and regulatory licenses are on the line, defendants and witnesses routinely spend 20x to 50x the disputed amount just to control the narrative and manage cross-jurisdictional risk.
  • Shared counsel creates massive gray areas. Before formal indictments drop, wealthy figures in the same orbit often hire the exact same elite lawyers. Until prosecutors officially pit them against each other in court, firms can legally bill multiple parties involved in the same investigation.
  • Witness status doesn't mean zero exposure. For a global executive, testimony given in a Tel Aviv courtroom can trigger a regulatory nuclear bomb in Sydney, London, or Las Vegas. Top lawyers charge millions specifically to prevent one jurisdiction's testimony from destroying a business somewhere else.

If you want to track how Case 1000 ultimately resolves, watch the final verdict on the breach of trust charges in the Jerusalem District Court rather than chasing rumors about Packer's invoices. The money already changed hands years ago, the testimony is in the record, and Packer has long since cashed out of the casino empire he paid millions to protect.

AR

Adrian Rodriguez

Drawing on years of industry experience, Adrian Rodriguez provides thoughtful commentary and well-sourced reporting on the issues that shape our world.